Exhaust Manifold Leak on a Heavy-Duty Diesel: Signs and Fix
An exhaust manifold leak on a heavy-duty diesel shows up as a tick on cold start that fades as the engine warms, soot at the slip joints or where the manifold meets the head, exhaust smell in the cab, and sometimes low power. Soot alone isn't a diagnosis. Find the exact leak point (slip joint, gasket, turbo joint or crack) before you order parts.
What are the signs of an exhaust manifold leak?
The classic sign is a sharp tick or puff you can hear near the manifold or turbo on a cold start that quiets as the engine comes up to temperature. PACCAR's E074 bulletin for the MX-13 explains why a leak is worst cold: the manifold joints partly seal through thermal expansion and a little soot (PACCAR E074). Navistar's IK1200949 describes the same thing, cold-start "whiffs" that seal as the engine first warms up (Navistar IK1200949).
Navistar's Big Bore exhaust manifold service procedure, IK1201253, lists the symptoms the OEM expects you to find (Navistar IK1201253):
- Soot at the slip joints between manifold sections.
- Soot where the head meets the manifold, at one or more ports.
- Exhaust smell in the cab. If you smell it, park the truck until it's fixed.
- Possible low power.
Add what you can see on a walk-around: a missing or broken stud, nut or capscrew at a port flange opens that joint. On Detroit GHG17 engines, the leak can also surface during fault-code diagnosis, which we cover below.
Is soot at the slip joints a leak worth fixing?
Soot alone, no. Soot plus power loss, dash warning lights or exhaust smell in the cab, yes. That's how the OEM bulletins line up when you read them together.
PACCAR E074 says soot at the front and rear slip joints of an MX-13 during initial break-in is expected, and warns that it can be misread as a failure and lead to parts replaced for nothing. A leak that comes with loss of power or dash warning lights needs investigating. Navistar's IK1200949 goes further on the EGR cooler-to-manifold "gooseneck" slip joint: an on-and-off leak there at cold start is normal, won't cause frequent regens or performance issues, and the manifold or gasket should not be replaced on soot alone. IK1201253, on the other hand, lists possible low power among leak symptoms.
Navistar adds two reading tips worth using on any engine. Heavy soot often won't show on the slip joint itself, because heat burns it off, so look at the underside of the heat shield and the cast surfaces nearby. And soot on the manifold flange or the head is often slip-joint soot mistaken for a gasket leak. Check the slip joint before you blame the gasket.
How do you find exactly where an exhaust manifold is leaking?
Work from the cheapest check to the most expensive and stop when you've found the joint. This order combines the shop walk-around with Detroit's exhaust leak diagnostic for DD13, DD15 and DD16 GHG17 engines (DDC-SVC-MAN-0191) and Navistar's IK1200949.
- Cold start and listen. A tick that fades as the engine warms points at the manifold.
- Look under the heat shield. Read the soot on its underside and on the nearby castings, not just at the joint.
- Trace where the soot starts. Between sections is a slip joint. At a single port is that port's gasket or fasteners. At the turbo inlet flange is the turbo joint.
- Count fasteners. One missing stud or nut is enough to open a port.
- Check the turbo-to-manifold joint and the turbo exhaust outlet. Detroit's procedure checks these (steps 9 and 10) before it gets to manifold torque and gaskets. A leak there looks like a manifold leak and takes different parts.
- Check manifold bolt torque against the OEM value for your engine (step 11). If torque is correct, Detroit has you replace the gasket.
- Inspect the manifold-to-head mating surfaces (step 12). Repair any damage and replace the gasket.
- Inspect the castings for cracks. Navistar's IK1200949 calls out the area around cylinder 4 on the engine it covers.
A smoke test with the engine off and cool helps on a joint you can't read, but a joint that only opens hot can pass cold. If the symptoms say leak and the test says nothing, recheck after a run under load.
Is it the manifold or the head gasket?
If exhaust symptoms come with coolant loss you can't explain, look past the manifold. Detroit's 23TS-06 on the Gen 5 DD15 describes a failed head gasket compression seal letting exhaust gas damage the upper liner O-ring, which shows up as an external coolant leak at the head-to-block joint (Detroit 23TS-06). Detroit says to leak-test the liner O-rings during that repair or risk pulling the head a second time. That's a head job, not a manifold job.
Fault codes can lead you to the manifold too. Detroit's SPN 3085 procedure for the MCM on GHG17 engines (the document is headed February 2016) includes a step to inspect the EGR and exhaust system for leaks (Detroit SPN 3085). The SPN 3563 procedure (January 2019) has you visually inspect the manifold, gaskets, turbine housing, EGR valve and aftertreatment device for leaks (Detroit SPN 3563). Rule out an exhaust leak before anyone condemns a turbo or a sensor.
OEM bulletins on exhaust manifold leaks, by engine
Each OEM names a different leak point and a different fix, so read the document for your engine before buying parts.
| Engine | Leak point named | OEM document | What it tells you to do |
|---|---|---|---|
| PACCAR MX-13 EPA2010 / EPA2013, three-piece manifold | Front and rear slip joints | E074 (7/19/2013); ESB E154 (released 9/9/2016, revised 9/21/2016) | Break-in soot is expected; fix-as-fail interim repair is remove, reinstall and seal |
| Cummins ISX15 / QSX15, three-piece manifold, all versions | Slip joints | TSB160030 (March 2016, revised November 2016) | New J-seal compatible sections; old and new sections can't be mixed |
| Detroit DD13 / DD15 / DD16 GHG17 | Turbo-to-manifold joint, turbo outlet, gasket, head mating face | DDC-SVC-MAN-0191 (April 2019) | Check in order; replace the gasket after the torque and surface checks |
| Navistar (engine covered by IK1200949) | EGR cooler-to-manifold gooseneck slip joint; cracks | IK1200949 | Cold-start leak at the gooseneck is normal; don't replace on soot alone |
| Navistar Big Bore | Slip joints; head-to-manifold joint | IK1201253 | Rear section, complete manifold or cuff procedure, by soot location |
| Cummins ISB6.7 CM2150 (medium duty) | Slip joints | Temporary Repair Practice replacing TRP 1338 | Refers you to Service Manual 4021578, procedures 11-007 and 11-027 |
We cite no OEM manifold-leak bulletin here for the Detroit Series 60 or the Cat 3406E and C15, so for those engines the service manual is the reference.
Can you replace just one section of a three-piece manifold?
On a Cummins ISX15 or QSX15, only if you can get a like section of the same design. Cummins TSB160030 introduced J-seal compatible sections for all three-piece manifolds on those engines to improve the slip joint's robustness against exhaust leaks, and the new sections are not compatible with the old ones (Cummins TSB160030). They can't be mixed. If you need one section and a like part isn't available, all sections must be replaced with the new design. Read the part number off each old section before you order.
| Section | Old part number | New part number |
|---|---|---|
| Center | 3104190 | 4386668 |
| Center | 3686601 | 4386724 |
| Center | 3680199 | 4386606 |
| Center | 3681490 | 4386649 |
| Center | 3100131 | 4386627 |
| Center | 3101341 | 4386797 |
| Center | 3682548 | 3682959 |
| End | 3682549 | 3683870 |
| End | 3680200 | 4386579 |
| End | 3682491 | 4952236 |
| End | 3688488 | Not superseded |
Navistar's Big Bore procedure decides by location. Soot at the head-to-manifold joint at cylinder 5 and/or 6 means replace the rear manifold. Soot at other cylinders means replace the complete manifold. Soot at the slip joints sends you to the exhaust cuff procedure.
Should you seal, update or replace the manifold?
Use the repair your engine's OEM documents call for. Sealant is an interim fix on one engine, not a general cure. PACCAR's ESB E154 covers MX-13 EPA2010 and EPA2013 engines with a three-piece manifold; it is fix-as-fail, and the interim repair is to remove and reinstall the manifold and apply sealant (PACCAR ESB E154). Cummins answered with updated sections, and Navistar with a cuff seal or a replacement manifold. None of the OEM procedures we reviewed offers a weld repair, so we replace a cracked casting rather than patch it.
E154 also gives the only OEM labor allowance we found for this job, and the full parts list:
| MX-13 build | Labor allowance | Parts listed in E154 |
|---|---|---|
| EPA2010 | 5.2 h (claim code E154A) | Qty 6 of 1639810PE exhaust manifold gasket |
| EPA2013 | 4.6 h (claim code E154B) | Qty 6 of 1899997PE exhaust manifold gasket; 1 of 1858037PE Usit ring; 2 of 1876833PE hose clamp; 1 of 1909939PE V-band clamp; 1 of 0331328PE copper sealing washer |
Add time for every stud that breaks on the way out. If you're replacing the manifold instead of resealing it, TTM lists the new Paccar MX13 exhaust manifold assembly, the Cummins ISX15 and X15 exhaust manifold and the Detroit Series 60 pre-EGR 12.7L/14.0L exhaust manifold. Check each product page for what's included and for fitment by build year.
How do you get the right mount position the first time?
Match three things before you order: the mount position and part number on the old manifold, the turbo location on the truck, and the listing. TTM sells the same engine family with manifolds in more than one mount position, and the listings name them: high, mid and low mount, plus an S mount on the Series 60 12.7L. The horsepower rating won't tell you which one you have, so read the old part.
| Listing | Engine | Mount position as listed |
|---|---|---|
| 681125 Detroit non-EGR high mount exhaust manifold kit | Detroit Series 60 12.7L / 14.0L non-EGR | High mount |
| 23516107 Series 60 S mount exhaust manifold | Detroit Series 60 12.7L | S mount |
| 2933586 Cat C15 ACERT high mount exhaust manifold | Cat C15 ACERT | High mount |
| 88002 ceramic coated mid mount exhaust manifold | Cat 3406E, C15, C16 | Mid mount |
If the listing, the old part and the truck don't agree, stop and call (713) 675-2435 with the numbers. A wrong order costs money: returns are accepted within 30 days of invoice with a 20% restocking fee unless the return is caused by a documented TTM error, and installed products are not returnable.
What should you replace while the manifold is off?
Our recommendation: replace everything that seals or holds the joint. It costs little next to doing the labor twice, and a reused stud that breaks on the second torque puts you right back where you started.
- Every gasket, stud and nut on the manifold, not just the broken ones.
- The turbo-to-manifold gasket and hardware, and on an MX-13 EPA2013 the full E154 list above.
- Turbo oil feed and drain line gaskets if you disturb those lines.
- The sealing faces. Check the head's exhaust face and the manifold flanges for flatness against the limit in the OEM service manual. If stud extraction damages the head face or a threaded hole, that's cylinder head work; TTM runs an in-house cylinder head shop and machine shop in Houston.
On an ISX15 or QSX15, the sections you put back must all be the same design (see TSB160030 above). On a Navistar Big Bore, the soot location decides whether you replace the rear section, the whole manifold or just the cuffs. Don't order until you've matched the old parts.
Where is the exhaust manifold torque spec?
In the OEM service manual for your engine, not in this article. We don't print a manifold torque value or tightening sequence, because we couldn't source one to a manufacturer document for these engines. Detroit's DDC-SVC-MAN-0191 tells you to check bolt torque but doesn't give the value in the excerpt we reviewed. Here's where each OEM keeps it:
- Cummins ISX15, X15, N14 and ISB: the service manual for your engine serial number in Cummins QuickServe. For the ISB6.7 CM2150, Cummins points to Service Manual 4021578, procedures 11-007 and 11-027.
- Detroit DD13, DD15 and DD16: the exhaust manifold removal and installation sections of Detroit's service literature, the same sections DDC-SVC-MAN-0191 refers to. Series 60: the Series 60 service manual.
- Cat 3406E, C15 and C16: Cat SIS, by engine serial number.
- PACCAR MX-13: the PACCAR engine service manual for your build.
Warranty terms for each part are on its product page and on the TTM warranty page. The warranty doesn't cover labor, diagnostics, removal and installation, towing, freight or downtime, and damage from improper installation or overheating voids coverage. If something goes wrong, notify TTM within 72 hours of detecting the issue and don't tear it down before TTM authorizes it in writing.
Frequently asked questions
Can I drive with an exhaust manifold leak?
If power is normal, no warning lights are on and no exhaust reaches the cab, the OEM bulletins treat it as something to investigate, not an emergency. PACCAR's E074 says a manifold leak that comes with loss of power or dash warning lights needs investigating, and Navistar lists exhaust smell in the cab and possible low power as leak symptoms. If you smell exhaust in the cab, park the truck until it's fixed. Otherwise, find the leak point and schedule the repair.
Is soot at the exhaust manifold slip joints normal on a new engine?
On a PACCAR MX-13, some soot at the front and rear slip joints during initial break-in is expected, according to PACCAR E074, because the joints partly seal through thermal expansion and a little soot. It needs investigating if it comes with power loss or dash warning lights. Navistar likewise says not to replace a manifold or gasket on soot alone. On other engines, treat fresh soot as a reason to watch and test, not to order parts.
How do I tell a manifold leak from a turbo-to-manifold seal leak?
Trace where the soot starts. Soot between manifold sections is a slip joint, soot at one port is that port's gasket or fasteners, and soot at the turbo inlet flange is the turbo joint, which takes a different gasket and hardware. Detroit's DDC-SVC-MAN-0191 checks the turbo-to-manifold joint and turbo exhaust outlet before manifold torque and gaskets. Look under the heat shield too, because heat can burn soot off the joint itself.
Can a cracked exhaust manifold be welded instead of replaced?
We recommend replacing it. None of the OEM procedures we reviewed offers a weld repair for a cracked manifold: PACCAR's E154 reseals with sealant as an interim fix, Cummins TSB160030 supplies updated sections, and Navistar calls for a cuff seal or a replacement manifold. On a three-piece manifold you may be able to replace only the cracked section, but on an ISX15 check TSB160030 first, because new and old sections can't be mixed.
Can I replace just one section of an ISX15 exhaust manifold?
Only with a like section of the same design. Cummins TSB160030 introduced J-seal compatible sections for all three-piece manifolds on ISX15 and QSX15 engines, and the new sections are not compatible with the old ones. If you need one section and a like part isn't available, all sections must be replaced with the new design. Read the part number off each old section and check it against the bulletin's supersession list before ordering.
Why are there high mount, mid mount and low mount manifolds for the same engine?
The same engine family is sold with manifolds in more than one mount position, and TTM's listings name them: high, mid and low mount, plus an S mount for the Series 60 12.7L. Which one you need depends on where the turbo sits on your truck, so match the mount position and part number on your old manifold, not the horsepower rating. If the listing and the truck don't agree, call (713) 675-2435 before you order.
Does an exhaust manifold leak set a fault code?
We found no dedicated manifold leak code in the OEM documents we reviewed, but a leak can surface while you chase other codes. On Detroit GHG17 engines, the SPN 3085 and SPN 3563 procedures include steps to inspect the exhaust system, manifold, gaskets and turbine housing for leaks. PACCAR says to investigate a manifold leak that comes with dash warning lights. Rule out an exhaust leak before condemning a turbo or a sensor.
What is the torque spec for exhaust manifold bolts on an ISX, Series 60 or C15?
Get it from the OEM service manual for your engine serial number. We couldn't source a manifold torque value or tightening sequence to a manufacturer document for these engines, so we don't print one. For Cummins, look up the manual by ESN in QuickServe; for Cat, use SIS by serial number; for the Series 60, use the Series 60 service manual. We recommend new studs, nuts and gaskets rather than reusing them.
Sources
- PACCAR E074, MX-13 exhaust manifold slip joint soot during break-in (7/19/2013)
- PACCAR ESB E154, PACCAR MX-13 Exhaust Manifold Leak (released 9/9/2016, revised 9/21/2016)
- Cummins TSB160030, J-seal compatible exhaust manifold sections, ISX15 and QSX15 (2016)
- Detroit DDC-SVC-MAN-0191, Symptom Diagnostics: Exhaust Leaks, HDEP GHG17 (April 2019)
- Detroit SPN 3085 (MCM) GHG17 diagnostic procedure (headed February 2016)
- Detroit SPN 3563 (MCM) GHG17 diagnostic procedure (January 2019)
- Detroit 23TS-06, Gen 5 DD15 head gasket compression seal and liner O-ring (7/14/2023)
- Navistar IK1200949, EGR cooler-to-manifold slip joint and exhaust manifold inspection
- Navistar IK1201253, Big Bore Exhaust Manifold Service Procedures
- Cummins ISB6.7 CM2150 Temporary Repair Practice, Exhaust Manifold Slip Joint Leaks